Used Toyota for Sale in Ithaca, NY Under $40,000

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$39,990
$39,990 above
$1,179/mo est. ?
26,153 km

Ferrario Auto Team

3.5
Star icon
9 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$12,500
$12,500 above
$369/mo est. ?
200,635 km 2.5L

Ferrario Ford

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.8 Google 590 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
high price
$33,990
$2,488 above
$1,002/mo est. ?
73,478 km 3.5L

Ferrario Ford

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.8 Google 590 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$11,995
$11,995 above
$354/mo est. ?
181,855 km 2.5L

Greg's Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

3.9 Google 74 reviews

13827, Owego NY

Check Details
$16,495
$16,495 above
$486/mo est. ?
222,750 km 2.5L

Upstate Auto Center

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
2 reviews

13045, Cortland West NY

Check Details
$27,499
$27,499 above
$811/mo est. ?
74,722 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$22,995
$22,995 above
$678/mo est. ?
141,229 km 3.5L

Ridge Road Imports

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.9
Star icon
8 reviews
4.7 Google 92 reviews

14882, Lansing NY

Check Details
$19,999
$19,999 above
$590/mo est. ?
98,144 km 2.5L

Maguire Nissan

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$28,799
$28,799 above
$849/mo est. ?
95,744 km

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$21,999
$21,999 above
$649/mo est. ?
94,056 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$30,999
$30,999 above
$914/mo est. ?
63,094 km

Simmons-Rockwell Buick GMC Cadillac Subaru

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.1 Google 26 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$31,999
$31,999 above
$944/mo est. ?
51,494 km 2.5L

Maguire Family of Dealerships

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$36,499
$36,499 above
$1,076/mo est. ?
49,046 km

Maguire Toyota

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$27,999
$27,999 above
$826/mo est. ?
36,653 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$35,999
$35,999 above
$1,062/mo est. ?
69,826 km

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$25,998
$25,998 above
$767/mo est. ?
50,965 km

Maguire Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM of Watkins Glen

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14891, Watkins Glen NY

Check Details
$28,499
$28,499 above
$840/mo est. ?
8,351 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$8,500
$8,500 above
$251/mo est. ?
230,562 km

C&C Auto LLC

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14845, Horseheads NY

Check Details
$12,900
$12,900 above
$380/mo est. ?
131,966 km

Jeff Kies Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

13732, Apalachin NY

Check Details
$20,999
$20,999 above
$619/mo est. ?
80,778 km

Maguire Honda of Ithaca

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$16,995
$16,995 above
$501/mo est. ?
191,511 km 3.5L

Greg's Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

3.9 Google 74 reviews

13827, Owego NY

Check Details
$26,500
$26,500 above
$781/mo est. ?
51,982 km 2.5L

Ridge Road Imports

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.9
Star icon
8 reviews
4.7 Google 92 reviews

14882, Lansing NY

Check Details
$29,999
$29,999 above
$885/mo est. ?
56,185 km 3.5L

Simmons-Rockwell Hyundai

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$34,665
$34,665 above
$1,022/mo est. ?
57,956 km 3.5L

Royal Motor Company

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

1.8
Star icon
4 reviews

13045, Cortland NY

Check Details