Used Toyota for Sale in Ithaca, NY

Showing 24 of 156 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$15,995
$15,995 above
$472/mo est. ?
149,987 km 2.5L

Tom Holleran's Auto

4.5
Star icon
2 reviews

14904, Elmira NY

Check Details
$44,299
$44,299 above
$1,306/mo est. ?
40,118 km 3.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$43,499
$43,499 above
$1,283/mo est. ?
64,380 km

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$29,999
$29,999 above
$885/mo est. ?
21,816 km

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$26,999
$26,999 above
$796/mo est. ?
128,546 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$30,999
$30,999 above
$914/mo est. ?
58,923 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$33,999
$33,999 above
$1,003/mo est. ?
93,760 km

Maguire Nissan

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$34,999
$34,999 above
$1,032/mo est. ?
42,372 km

Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota)

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$14,995
$14,995 above
$442/mo est. ?
217,261 km

14845, Horseheads NY

Check Details
$20,499
$20,499 above
$604/mo est. ?
23,368 km 2.0L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$38,499
$38,499 above
$1,135/mo est. ?
54,674 km 3.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$28,998
$28,998 above
$855/mo est. ?
34,746 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$24,999
$24,999 above
$737/mo est. ?
46,486 km 2.0L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$31,899
$31,899 above
$941/mo est. ?
32,364 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$56,999
$56,999 above
$1,681/mo est. ?
24,517 km

Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota)

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$10,000
$10,000 above
$295/mo est. ?
205,231 km

Budget Autos

4.4 Google 16 reviews

13790, Johnson City NY

Check Details
$32,999
$32,999 above
$973/mo est. ?
109,989 km

Maguire Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram Fiat Ithaca

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$34,999
$34,999 above
$1,032/mo est. ?
87,909 km

Maguire Toyota

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$36,999
$36,999 above
$1,091/mo est. ?
73,759 km

Maguire Toyota

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$41,999
$41,999 above
$1,238/mo est. ?
39,788 km

Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota)

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details
$24,999
$24,999 above
$737/mo est. ?
52,521 km 2.5L

Williams Toyota Of Elmira

4.4 Google 230 reviews

14903, Elmira NY

Check Details
$31,999
$31,999 above
$944/mo est. ?
78,526 km 2.5L

Royal Chrysler Motors

13827, Owego NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
222,937 km

Montour Motors

14865, Montour Falls NY

Check Details
$46,999
$46,999 above
$1,386/mo est. ?
17,799 km

Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota)

14850, Ithaca NY

Check Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Our marketplace currently lists 156 used cars in Ithaca, NY from dealers and private sellers. Prices range from $14,595 to $61,716.

Top brands by active listings in Ithaca, NY are Toyota. The mix often reflects local buying preferences.

The average listed price in Ithaca, NY is $33,680. Browse by budget: under $10,000, under $20,000, or under $30,000.

No — you can buy from a seller in Ithaca, NY regardless of your state of residence. You'll need to register and title the vehicle in your home state within the required window (usually 30 days). Local dealers typically handle paperwork for out-of-state buyers.

Yes — popular nearby options include cities across the state. You can also browse all used cars in New York.