Page № 86 - Used Subaru for Sale Under $5,000 Near Me

Showing 24 of 2,097 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$5,000
$5,000 above
$147/mo est. ?
305,956 km

Lincoln of Cincinnati

45242, Cincinnati OH

Check Details
$4,995
$4,995 above
$147/mo est. ?
235,858 km 3.6L

New Creation Auto Sales

98204, Everett WA

Check Details
$150
$150 above
$4/mo est. ?
271,191 km 2.5L

Auto Depot LLC

37311, Cleveland TN

Check Details
$4,400
$4,400 above
$130/mo est. ?
300,934 km

Classic Motor Cars

4.1 Google 9 reviews

06108, East Hartford CT

Check Details
$4,999
$4,999 above
$147/mo est. ?
295,618 km

06790, Torrington CT

Check Details
$2,900
$2,900 above
$86/mo est. ?
354,489 km

Car 2 Sell

4.1 Google 679 reviews

07205, Hillside NJ

Check Details
$4,998
$4,998 above
$147/mo est. ?
274,072 km

Walushka Auto House

28460, Sneads Ferry NC

Check Details
$5,000
$5,000 above
$147/mo est. ?
286,780 km

Ramsey Subaru

4.2 Google 681 reviews

50322, Urbandale IA

Check Details
$3,995
$3,995 above
$118/mo est. ?
372,282 km

Alpine Ford

81008, Pueblo CO

Check Details
$3,495
$3,495 above
$103/mo est. ?
231,330 km

Goodwin Chevrolet

4.6 Google 282 reviews

04270, Oxford ME

Check Details
$4,800
$4,800 above
$142/mo est. ?
200,831 km

28711, Black Mountain NC

Check Details
$3,900
$3,900 above
$115/mo est. ?
174,145 km

Laramie GM Auto Center

82070, Laramie WY

Check Details
$4,995
$4,995 above
$147/mo est. ?
310,138 km

National Motors

4.7 Google 53 reviews

99037, Spokane Valley WA

Check Details
$4,500
$4,500 above
$133/mo est. ?
321,611 km

Handy Toyota

05478, St Albans VT

Check Details
$2,999
$2,999 above
$88/mo est. ?
255,563 km 2.5L

CAP Enterprises

3.5
Star icon
2 reviews
3.0 Google 4 reviews

57105, Sioux Falls SD

Check Details
$1
$1 above
2 km 2.5L

48219, Detroit MI

Check Details
$2,888
$2,888 above
$85/mo est. ?
311,427 km

AutoFair Hyundai

4.7 Google 2721 reviews

03103, Manchester NH

Check Details
$4,200
$4,200 above
$124/mo est. ?
234,593 km

Grizzly Garage

44147, Broadview Heights OH

Check Details
$4,502
$4,502 above
$133/mo est. ?
254,813 km

Danbury Hyundai

4.2 Google 1038 reviews

06810, Danbury CT

Check Details
$1,495
$1,495 above
$44/mo est. ?
368,547 km 2.5L

43113, Circleville OH

Check Details
$75
$75 above
$2/mo est. ?
218,624 km 2.0L

Route 8 Auto Sales

4.6
Star icon
3 reviews

16301, Oil City PA

Check Details
$5,000
$5,000 above
$147/mo est. ?
242,388 km 2.5L

Route 52 Auto

3.9 Google 54 reviews

47906, West Lafayette IN

Check Details
$4,500
$4,500 above
$133/mo est. ?
232,200 km

33584, Seffner FL

Check Details
$3,995
$3,995 above
$118/mo est. ?
274,718 km

NMM Used Cars

07753, Neptune NJ

Check Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Our marketplace lists 2,097 Subaru cars priced under $5,000. The most popular options in this price range are Subaru Forester, Subaru Outback, Subaru Impreza, and Subaru Legacy. Average price is $2,989.

The average mileage in this price range is 164,385 miles. Expect newer, lower-mileage units toward the top of the budget and older but well-maintained ones at the lower end.

Yes — used vehicles in this price range can offer strong value retention when you focus on reliable models with documented service history. Look for one-owner cars and recent maintenance records.

If you're flexible, look at Subaru under $10,000 — comparable in reliability and value. For more variety, browse all used cars under $5,000.

You can also browse SUVs under $5,000, Sedans under $5,000, and Wagons under $5,000 or expand your budget to the next tier. Popular options across body styles include Subaru Forester, Subaru Outback, Subaru Impreza, and Subaru Legacy.