Used Toyota for Sale in Indianapolis, IN Under $40,000

Showing 24 of 1,617 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$30,198
$30,198 above
$890/mo est. ?
75,050 km 2.5L

46219, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$24,860
$24,860 above
$733/mo est. ?
79,905 km 2.5L

Omega AutoSports

46038, Fishers IN

Check Details
$20,998
$20,998 above
$619/mo est. ?
111,716 km 1.8L

CarMax Indianapolis

1.7
Star icon
8 reviews

46280, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$7,500
$7,500 above
$221/mo est. ?
211,050 km

California Auto Sales

4.8 Google 31 reviews

46222, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$25,988
$25,988 above
$766/mo est. ?
216,862 km

Tom O'Brien Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram - Greenwood

46142, Greenwood IN

Check Details
$19,731
$19,731 above
$582/mo est. ?
110,457 km

Andy Mohr Toyota

46123, Avon IN

Check Details
$14,347
$14,347 above
$423/mo est. ?
168,759 km

Andy Mohr Toyota

46123, Avon IN

Check Details
$18,452
$18,452 above
$544/mo est. ?
178,651 km

Andy Mohr Toyota

46123, Avon IN

Check Details
$18,963
$18,963 above
$559/mo est. ?
213,913 km

Andy Mohr Toyota

46123, Avon IN

Check Details
$5,900
$5,900 above
$174/mo est. ?
232,909 km 4.7L

A Better Bid Online Car Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
3.7 Google 199 reviews

46034, CICERO IN

Check Details
$22,599
$22,599 above
$666/mo est. ?
207,587 km

Kahlo Chrysler Dodge Jeep

4.5 Google 1678 reviews

46060, Noblesville IN

Check Details
$19,977
$19,977 above
$589/mo est. ?
115,935 km

Hubler Chevrolet Center

4.0 Google 270 reviews

46176, Shelbyville IN

Check Details
$10,450
$10,450 above
$308/mo est. ?
159,919 km

Sinclair Auto Inc

4.4 Google 36 reviews

46064, Pendleton IN

Check Details
$27,297
$27,297 above
$805/mo est. ?
34,778 km

Andy Mohr Toyota

46123, Avon IN

Check Details
$11,995
$11,995 above
$354/mo est. ?
185,063 km 2.5L

Z Imports

46227, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$26,528
$26,528 above
$781/mo est. ?
0 km

Tom Wood Toyota

46075, Whitestown IN

Check Details
$18,854
$18,854 above
$556/mo est. ?
214,626 km

Ray Skillman Ford

4.5 Google 1698 reviews

46143, Greenwood IN

Check Details
$17,980
$17,980 above
$530/mo est. ?
247,122 km

Ray Skillman Ford

4.5 Google 1698 reviews

46143, Greenwood IN

Check Details
$29,860
$29,860 above
$881/mo est. ?
97,262 km

46240, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$26,460
$26,460 above
$780/mo est. ?
75,060 km

46240, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$16,900
$16,900 above
$498/mo est. ?
108,787 km 2.5L

Unique Auto Group

4.0
Star icon
8 reviews

46241, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$6,999
$6,999 above
$206/mo est. ?
117,929 km 2.4L

Indy Star Motors

3.3 Google 64 reviews

46217, Indianapolis IN

Check Details
$23,700
$23,700 above
$699/mo est. ?
110,101 km

AutoSavvy Fishers

46038, Fishers IN

Check Details
$39,588
$39,588 above
$1,165/mo est. ?
0 km 2.0L

Ed Martin Toyota

46060, Noblesville IN

Check Details