Page № 4 - Used BMW for Sale in Amherst, NY

Showing 24 of 177 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$29,999
$29,999 above
$885/mo est. ?
89,730 km

Basil Resale Sheridan

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$17,963
$17,963 above
$530/mo est. ?
70,819 km

Basil Ford Buffalo New and Used Cars

14225, Buffalo NY

Check Details
$75,919
$75,919 above
$2,239/mo est. ?
30,737 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$36,801
$36,801 above
$1,085/mo est. ?
36,975 km

Northtown Mazda

4.6 Google 803 reviews

14226, Amherst NY

Check Details
$50,998
$50,998 above
$1,504/mo est. ?
24,274 km

CarMax

14228, Amherst NY

Check Details
$22,958
$22,958 above
$677/mo est. ?
94,972 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$13,775
$13,775 above
$406/mo est. ?
77,083 km

Basil Volkswagen

4.7 Google 659 reviews

14094, Lockport NY

Check Details
$39,279
$39,279 above
$1,158/mo est. ?
88,240 km

David Chevrolet

14304, Niagara Falls NY

Check Details
$22,495
$22,495 above
$663/mo est. ?
126,143 km

Galaxy Auto Place

4.6 Google 222 reviews

14224, West Seneca NY

Check Details
$87,907
$87,907 above
$2,592/mo est. ?
11,986 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$24,888
$24,888 above
$734/mo est. ?
89,729 km

Northtown Lexus

4.5 Google 441 reviews

14226, Amherst NY

Check Details
$19,496
$19,496 above
$575/mo est. ?
109,044 km

Basil Toyota

14094, Lockport NY

Check Details
$20,900
$20,900 above
$616/mo est. ?
96,634 km

Basil Resale Sheridan

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$16,996
$16,996 above
$501/mo est. ?
155,446 km

West Herr Lincoln

14068, Getzville NY

Check Details
$59,911
$59,911 above
$1,767/mo est. ?
18,519 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$57,785
$57,785 above
$1,704/mo est. ?
38,957 km

Genesis of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$17,889
$17,889 above
$528/mo est. ?
83,808 km

Northtown Lexus

4.5 Google 441 reviews

14226, Amherst NY

Check Details
$60,916
$60,916 above
$1,796/mo est. ?
26,564 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$45,932
$45,932 above
$1,354/mo est. ?
52,934 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$49,414
$49,414 above
$1,457/mo est. ?
22,286 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$49,908
$49,908 above
$1,472/mo est. ?
13,555 km

BMW of Buffalo

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$52,995
$52,995 above
$1,563/mo est. ?
22,302 km

Maranello Alfa Romeo Maserati of Western New York

14221, Williamsville NY

Check Details
$14,900
$14,900 above
$439/mo est. ?
123,919 km

Paul Herman Motor Cars

3.6 Google 49 reviews

14216, Buffalo NY

Check Details
$17,901
$17,901 above
$528/mo est. ?
69,202 km

Paul Herman Motor Cars

3.6 Google 49 reviews

14216, Buffalo NY

Check Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Our marketplace currently lists 177 used cars in Amherst, NY from dealers and private sellers. Prices range from $17,514 to $55,461.

Top brands by active listings in Amherst, NY are Bmw. The mix often reflects local buying preferences.

The average listed price in Amherst, NY is $33,956. Browse by budget: under $10,000, under $20,000, or under $30,000.

No — you can buy from a seller in Amherst, NY regardless of your state of residence. You'll need to register and title the vehicle in your home state within the required window (usually 30 days). Local dealers typically handle paperwork for out-of-state buyers.

Yes — popular nearby options include cities across the state. You can also browse all used cars in New York.